Not sure if you know Margaret Pomeranz and David Stratton from ABC's At the Movies.
Margaret gives 2.5 stars
David gives 3 stars
Here's their review..
http://www.abc.net.au/atthemovies/txt/s2005051.htmFurReview by Margaret PomeranzFUR opened the inaugural Rome Film Festival last year and because it starred NICOLE KIDMAN as the legendary New York photographer Diane Arbus we’ve been hanging out for it to get a release in this country.
Creeping into cinemas next week it depicts Arbus as a circumscribed upper class New Yorker, married to Allen, (TY BURRELL), whom she assists in his photography business.
But she’s a woman totally under the thumb of her domineering parents. When a mysterious stranger moves in upstairs her life changes. Lionel Sweeney, (ROBERT DOWNEY JR), is a neighbour like no other.
It’s through Lionel that Arbus will be introduced to the world that will make her famous through her photographs.
There’s something very odd about this film. It’s billed as an imaginary portrait of the artist but even fantasy has to have a touch of reality to it.
Robert Downey Jr. looks as if he can barely stifle a laugh let alone get words out from behind all that fur. Lionel’s look was designed by the Stan Winston Studios but I was not convinced.
Such oddity needs some sort of conviction but except for husband Allen, the characters are presented superficially as freaks or as demons.
As for the metaphor of Arbus being seduced away from the rigidity of her life by the charm of otherness, it just doesn’t give enough substance to her extraordinary art. It demeans it somehow.
It’s a bit of a disappointment from the creative team of director Steven Shainburg and screenwriter Erin Cressida Wilson who brought us the delightfully different SECRETARY.
NICOLE KIDMAN is fragile and questing as Arbus but she’s really not given very much to work with here.
Further comments
MARGARET: David?
DAVID: Well, I thought this was really interesting. I mean, I think the first thing to say is that if you're not familiar with the work of Diane Arbus the film will mean nothing to you because...
MARGARET: Yes, most probably if you're not familiar you should look her up on the net and...
DAVID: I think you should, to see the photographs...
MARGARET: Yes.
DAVID: ...that she took, because obviously the film is suggesting that she was influenced by the events or similar, anyway, events in the film in the work she did later. I think Nicole Kidman actually is good in this. I think she gives one of her better performances.
MARGARET: But...
DAVID: I found her very interesting; her journey a very interesting one. It's a sort of beauty and the beast story, isn't it? I mean...
MARGARET: Well, yes, obviously.
DAVID: Obviously. But I mean, Robert Downey Jr, I think looks a bit like the beast in Cocteau's...
MARGARET: Yes, I was going to say that, you know.
DAVID: Yeah. And it is really strange. It's very strange, but I don't know, the basic set up is vaguely similar to that of SECRETARY. I mean, a young woman who is, kind of becomes obsessed, erotically obsessed, with somebody...
MARGARET: Some strange man.
DAVID: Yes. Somebody very different.
MARGARET: Yes.
DAVID: And so there's a - there's a linking theme there and I agree with you, it's so odd it doesn't quite come off but I thought it was a brave try, this.
MARGARET: You know, it's that hair on Robert Downey Jr.
DAVID: No, I didn't mind that at all. I wanted to stroke it.
MARGARET: No, no, no.